Thursday, September 23 2021

First American Financial Corp. agreed to a settlement with the Securities and Exchange Commission for failures in disclosure controls and procedures of cybersecurity vulnerabilities.

According to the SEC order, First American’s file-sharing application leaked over 800 million images, including bank account numbers and statements, mortgage and tax records, Social Security numbers, wire transaction receipts, and driver licenses. First American agreed to a $487,616 settlement for violations related to a vulnerability in its EaglePro application.

Yes, you read that correctly. To place the settlement in context, First American and its insurance subsidiaries held the second-largest market share in the title insurance industry, approximately 27% market share as of August 2017, according to Fitch Ratings.

Alex Sharpe, principal at Sharpe Management Consulting LLC, told SecureDisruptions.com he was “skeptical” that the settlement would induce good cyber hygiene.

This data is valuable “and it needs to be protected to the level of that value,” he added. “The amount of the perceived fine will dictate how much an organization is willing to invest in preventing the loss.”

We’re pretty sure this isn’t what Grace Hopper meant when she said, ‘It’s easier to ask forgiveness than it is to get permission,’ but… whatever.

If NYDFS Doesn’t Get You, the SEC Will… Sort Of.

First American’s insurance subsidiary was the first company to face charges of the New York State Department of Financial Services’ Cybersecurity Regulation violations in July 2020. The case with NYSDFS is ongoing.

Brian Krebs, an investigative cybersecurity journalist, first reported the exposed transaction images in May 2019. He called the settlement “farcical” in a recent blog after the settlement announcement.

The SEC “appears to have taken care to be thoughtful in not second-guessing good faith decisions about whether to disclose security vulnerabilities,” King & Spalding LLP partner Bill Johnson told SecureDisruptions.com.

At a May 2018 Congressional hearing, former SEC Enforcement co-directors Stephanie Avakian and Steven Peikin noted the challenges of disclosing cyberattacks. The officials expressed a hesitation to “second-guess good-faith disclosure decisions,” although they warned that some circumstances warrant enforcement actions.

Sharpe noted the limitations of regulatory reluctance to “second-guess” disclosure decisions. “They’re not Monday morning quarterbacking it,” he said. “They’re judging the result.”

The SEC released cybersecurity disclosure guidance in February 2018. In announcing the revised guidance, former Chairman Jay Clayton noted “the importance of policies and procedures related to disclosure controls and procedures, insider trading, and selective disclosures.”

Johnson, a former Enforcement Division attorney at the regulator, said the settlement is consistent with the 2018 guidance and other public statements by SEC officials, “all of which emphasized the need for company employees with knowledge of security vulnerabilities to share that information with those responsible for making SEC disclosures.”

Previous

As Ransomware Soars, Insurers Mull Changes

Next

Financial sector has not implemented cybersecurity measures: Deloitte

Check Also

Widget

Don’t Miss

Cyber Deal Update: Upstream Security, Hunters, build.security

Khushi Arora

Upstream Security and Hunters complete Series C and Series A funding rounds, respectively. Elastic NV acquires build.security. Funding Upstream Security, an Israeli provider of automotive cybersecurity and a data analytics platform for connected vehicles, has closed a $62 million Series C funding round led by Mitsui Sumitomo Insurance, along with new investors I.D.I. Insurance, NextGen […]

Cyber Deal Update: Loop Secure, Intelligent Automation, Blumira

Khushi Arora

Tesserent acquires Loop Secure to complement its own services, and BlueHalo merges with Intelligent Automation. Blumira completes a Series A funding round. Mergers and Acquisitions Tesserent, an Australian network security company, has announced its intent to acquire Loop Secure, a provider of managed security services, governance risk and compliance, and offensive security services also based […]

Cyber Deal Update: FHIRBlocks, InfoSum

Khushi Arora

Healthcare cybersecurity company ConsenSys Health acquires FHIRBlocks. InfoSum and Monte Carlo close a Series B and Series C funding round, respectively. Mergers and Acquisitions Otava, a Michigan-headquartered cloud solutions provider, has announced its acquisition of NewCloud Networks, a Colorado-based cloud computing services provider. The acquisition provides Otava a product portfolio that includes security services, cloud […]

Cyber Deal Update: Carve Systems, Baffle, Certik

Khushi Arora

iVision acquires Carve Systems, Baffle closes a Series B funding round, and CertiK closes adds to its Series B funding round announced last month. Mergers and Acquisitions iVision, a Georgia-based provider of IT infrastructure and application solutions, has acquired Carve Systems, a New York-based cybersecurity company that provides security testing, security engineering, and security strategy […]

Cyber Executive Moves: Aegon Asset Management, Tego Cyber

Khushi Arora

Aegon Asset Management hires former COO of MN and Tego Cyber gains a new CISO. Aegon Asset Management, based in The Netherlands, has appointed Nicole Grootveld-Sandig as its chief technology officer. Grootveld-Sandig joins Aegon from the Dutch specialist pensions management company MN NV. Tego Cyber, a Nevada-based developer of cyber threat intelligence solutions, has hired […]

Cyber Deal Update: Appriss Insights, Espagon

Khushi Arora

Equifast acquires data analytics company Appriss Insights, while Cisco acquires observability provider Espagon. Mergers and Acquisitions Equifax, an Atlanta-based global data, analytics and technology company, has announced its acquisition of Appriss Insights, a Kentucky-based information technology company providing customized solutions to enhance security and financial processes for businesses, for $1.825 billion. “We are extending the […]